The Avengers [2012]
2012 has its fair share of heavily anticipated movies. Seeing as Prometheus, The Dark Knight Rises and Les Misérables haven’t come out yet and are not very likely to disappoint, and The Hunger Games certainly didn’t, I can say that The Avengers is my first big cinematic letdown of the year. I won’t go so far as to say it’s a terrible movie, because it’s not; how could it be with that team? It just doesn’t live up to the massive hype. This Joss Whedon-directed, huge-budget actioner, with its humongous marketing campaign and a couple very good movies as precedents, is generally silly, overly long and even…boring (cue gasp!)
Most fight sequences are riveting displays of excellent choreography and the main cast, with the notable exception of the wooden Chris Hemsworth, is once again great in the skin of their super-powered alter egos: Chris Evans as Steve Rogers/Captain America plays earnest without a tinge of irony, Robert Downey Jr. is his usual cool self as genius/billionaire/playboy/philanthropist Tony Stark aka Iron Man, Mark Ruffalo proves he was an inspired choice to play Bruce Banner/Hulk after incarnations by Ed Norton and Eric Bana, while Scarlett Johansson shines and kicks ass every time she’s on screen, especially that interrogation scene, one of two absolutely perfect sequences in the movie. As a fan of the sitcom How I Met Your Mother and one of its stars, Cobie Smulders, as well as of Jeremy Renner’s brooding, tough guy persona, it’s a little sad their talents were so heavily underused.
As is often the case, the villain steals the show. Tom Hiddleston is superb as Loki and, just as it happened a year ago with Thor, he deserved a better film to wreak havoc in. When he crashes a fancy party in Stuttgart and steals a man’s eye (seriously), that’s the best scene in the whole film. It needed more of those. The main issue with The Avengers, and what made it extremely hard for me to enjoy it, was its cheesy, misplaced humor, which it could’ve done very well without. Comic book adaptations and superhero movies are silly enough and hard to take seriously as it is for someone to add humor to the mix. The Avengers could have been groundbreaking, but underneath the spectacle, it’s the same old loud and dumb mess of summer.
Wow. This is literally the first bad review I’ve read of this film. At least I have to respect your commitment to your own feelings and not follow the crowd. I’m worried now because the reviews for this film has been some of the highest I’ve ever read. People have been praising this film with such adjectives that place it somewhere between Citizen Kane and The Godfather. I’ll be seeing it Friday, but I’m glad I read your review so my expectations won’t be as unrealistic anymore. Nicely written as always.
LikeLike
Yes! I was surprised I didn’t enjoy it, because I was very excited for the film and had read a lot of praise. I understand why people would love it, but you’re right, the level of praise is comparable to that of films like Citizen Kane. I can’t explain it. I think they’re totally overreacting.
LikeLike
I thought you might find this article amusing: http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/avengers-samuel-l-jackson-slams-ao-scott-ny-times-review-319966
LikeLike
Thanks for sharing. I’ll read it in a few.
LikeLike
Glad to know I’m not alone in disliking Avengers. I agree that the talent might feel offended when critics bash on their work but I think Jackson took it way too personally. “And I will strike down upon thee with great vengeance and furious anger those who would attempt to talk badly about my movies. And you will know My name is Samuel L. when I lay My vengeance upon thee, A.O. Scott!”
LikeLike
Who knew that a man who plays a badass in so many films, could be so sensitive? LOL
LikeLike
Just like Mark, this is the first review I have read the hasn’t praised it. Will take your things into account so I don’t go in expecting a masterpiece. Great review.
LikeLike
Thanks, man! I really had a hard time trying to enjoy it. I couldn’t get past the silly humor. Hope everybody enjoys it more than I did.
LikeLike
Great review as always, Fernando! I have absolutely no intention of seeing this, even on DVD. These comic book films are churned out on an endless conveyor belt and when they shove a group of them together, it smacks of desperation. I’ll be interested in reading other reviews, but I gave up on Marvel quite a while ago.
LikeLike
Thanks, Andy! I haven’t quite given up on Marvel but I couldn’t enjoy this, no matter how hard I tried. I don’t like humor in films like these is all.
LikeLike
This is the first negative review I’ve read about this film, so I’m quite surprised. I can agree with your statement that it’s overlong, even without seeing it. 2 hours and 23 minutes just seems too long for this kind of movie. I’ll probably see it Saturday. If not, I’ll have to wait for it to come to DVD because my school play will be over the following two weekends. D8
LikeLike
You should see it, I’m looking forward to reading your thoughts on it. And I bet you’ll be able to watch it since it probably will stay at theaters for a long time.
LikeLike
Yeah, I’ve also been looking to watch Bernie with Jack Black as well as Marley, but it seems they left my local theaters before I could say, “Damn it.” (Fitting that I said it afterward.)
LikeLike
Good review Fernando but, as you already know, I’m going to have to disagree. I think the movie was fantastic. I’ve seen it twice now and it was just as good the second time. I don’t think the humour was cheesy; like in all Joss Whedon’s work it was organic and came from the characters instead of everyone being a non-stop gag machine. I don’t want to go into details for those who haven’t seen it yet, but all the jokes and visual gags were earned from a story perspective. The way all the leads had been set up in their earlier films made it seem to me that this is how they would actually interact: their initial dislike and distrust coming through as snark and sarcasm, particularly where Tony Stark is concerned.
I’m no Marvel fanboy but I enjoyed all the earlier MCU movies. Some were better than others of course, but for me this was the right way to do an Avengers flick. As for the length, the 2 and a half hours really flies by. You could argue the second act feels a little padded at times, but every scene adds something either in tone or plot. You would be hard pressed to chop more than 15 minutes without leaving things wanting. As it is, there’s apparently about 30 minutes of deleted scenes going to be on the DVD!
LikeLike
Hey Fernando, interesting review although I must admit that I couldn’t disagree more. My review should be up today on my site but I think that it is deftly handled by Whedon in bringing all of the characters together without short-changing them (though that is generally his strength) and, having seen it twice, the humour has gone down very well with two packed audiences. We’ll have to agree to disagree!
LikeLike
Those are some very valid points, gentlemen, but like Ben said, we’ll have to agree to disagree.
LikeLike
Oh no! Bummer that you didn’t enjoy this man. I’m seeing this tonight, and quite excited about it. Well you at least help me manage my expectations and balance out all those stellar reviews.
Btw, happy Cinco de Mayo!!
LikeLike
Yeah. I didn’t enjoy it but I hope you will. Have fun tonight! And thanks again 🙂
LikeLike
I enjoyed this, but not all that much. I really can’t comprehend all the hype.
http://themoviefreakblog.com/2012/05/05/review-marvels-the-avengers/
LikeLike
THANK YOU!
LikeLike
Happy Cinco de Mayo! How are you celebrating?
LikeLike
Thanks. I’m not celebrating, actually. Normal day for me. It’s a bigger deal over at the US, believe it or not. It’s sort of important a bit further down the country, at the capital and of course, Puebla, where the battle happened but it’s not as big as, say, Independence Day (September 15th).
LikeLike
Oh whoops. I thought today was the Mexican Independence Day. Didn’t know it was September 15th. My father saw a drunken college student, today, wearing a massive sombrero and a Hawaiian lay (however you spell that word) and shouting, “¡HOLA, MI HOMBRE!” He wasn’t even Mexican. So yes, it must be muuch bigger in the USA…
LikeLike
That’s OK. A lot of people outside Mexico don’t know that either. Now you do, though. And I bet it was funny seeing that guy drunkenly perpetuate not one but two cultural stereotypes! hahahah Cinco de Mayo over there is pretty much a drinking holiday (that’s why some people say it’s the Mexican St. Patrick’s Day) and since you’re way below the legal drinking age, I don’t think you’ll get much out of celebrating it haha
LikeLike
Aah I was so scared to read your review, Fernando! Although it’s not as bad as I thought it would be. I felt so guilty of hyping it up too much, so much so I’m worried that I watched it so in awe that if I saw it again now I wouldn’t love it as much.
I think your comments are completely fair, and Tom Hiddleston is amazing as Loki. I too would have liked to see Renner and Johansson on screen a little more, but talk of their own spin off movie has certainly got me excited.
Excellent review, and poster choice, as always!
LikeLike
Thanks! 🙂 I wasn’t too harsh, right? I didn’t hate the movie, there were some very good aspects to it. And yeah, that tends to happen when you see a very anticipated movie and you’re wowed that first time but it gradually loses something with repeated viewings. A Black Widow/Hawkeye spinoff would be cool, though. Scarlett and Jeremy have the action hero thing down. They’re great actors, great-looking and can kick ass!
LikeLike
I got the sense from some of the reviews I’ve read that most were disappointed in the movie in some way but then rationalized that there was plenty of stuff to make up for it. It’s nice to see someone give an honest review. I’m seeing it tomorrow! hehe, if you go in knowing it doesn’t quite match the hype then you are more likely to walk out perfectly happy. Cheers!
LikeLike
Thanks. You’re absolutely right. Hope you enjoy it. I didn’t hate it, it just let me down, you know? And what worked for most (the humor) completely didn’t for me.
LikeLike
Pingback: My new BFF « fernandorafael
Pingback: Movie Questionnaire « Committed to Celluloid
Pingback: 2012 in Review « Cinemaniac Reviews
Pingback: My Movie Alphabet: Pt. III « Committed to Celluloid
Pingback: Final predictions before the big night! | Committed to Celluloid
Pingback: Spotlight on the finest performers of 2012 | Committed to Celluloid
Pingback: My top 10 films of 2012 (yes, in March) | Committed to Celluloid
Pingback: Flash Review: Iron Man 3 | Committed to Celluloid
Pingback: 12 Days of Christmas Swap: Days 8 through 10 | Committed to Celluloid
Pingback: Captain America: The Winter Soldier [2014] | Committed to Celluloid
Pingback: X-Men: Days of Future Past [2014] | Committed to Celluloid
Pingback: The top 10 actors that I’d see in pretty much anything | Committed to Celluloid